Okay, I hate messy arguments. Right now that’s just what we have on our hands. I think right now it’s up to Pliedes to Clean up his Posts.
Summary (extremely abbreviated version):
DH – “I don’t believe in Hell”.
Pli - "Just because you don't believe it doesn't mean it's not true".
Titan - “Just because you do, doesn’t mean it does.
*Pli- “[above quote] not a rule”. “used to show people fault in stated position”.
Titan – “[*everyone’s head spins]”
No offense Pli, but that sounded like one hell (no pun intended) of a campaign for being able to use an ontological argument in support of your position. I knew where you were going with it as soon as you started and it still made my head spin (thanks Titan).
So the task put before you Pliedes is this, Clean up this mess:
Rule or Simple Statement
What "Inherent" Flaw?
Is your Argument on the “Inherent Flaw” going to be based Ontologically or Not?
(cool either way just make it clear).
Go.
[ December 14, 2003, 06:04 PM: Message edited by: Percipere'Chan ]
|