First of all, let's not get ahead of ourselves. I didn't actually state my position. (though Percipitation, being the clever fellow he is, added followed it to it's result)
At the time, Dirty Harry had just made the comment "I don't believe in hell". And I replied with "Just because you don't believe in something, doens't mean it doesn't exist".
Now, what I was stating at the time was more of a general comment on attitudes. The little kid in "The Santa Clause" provides us with an example. His step-father was trying to convince him that Santa Claus does not exist, and when he stated..."I've never seen Santa Clause", to which the child responds "Have you ever seen a million dollars?", [step-father replies] "No." [child again] "That doesn't mean it doesn't exist."
In the same way, I was simply saying that a person believing something does not exist, does not mean that it doesn't exist. It only means that a person doesn't believe in it.
-BUT- (and this is where Percipitation connected the dots)
If we can in any way state that something has an underlying validity beyond a state such as human belief then it ultimately is an ontological arguement.
[I hope that clears things up, Percy]
I'm still not ready to dive head first into all this jazz, but something Hank brought up in another thread which caught my eye, was Pascal's wager.
I think many nubblites will find it interesting, as many are gambling men. It's actually really simple, and as follows:
If you place your bets on God existing and you are right, you have much to gain, and if you are wrong, you lose nothing. Whereas if you place your bet on God not existing, and you are wrong, you have much to lose, but if you are right, you gain nothing.
Or as Pascal said, "If you gain, you gain all; if you lose, you lose nothing."
Extremely generalized, but that's what he was getting at.
Let's bat that around for a while.
|