What you fail to note is that "inelastic" is a relative term. Everything... even insulin, is elastic to a point, and oil is no exception. There are prices at which Americans consume less oil. Do you think Americans drive as much now as they did 2 years ago? Not likely. People no longer take as many "pleasure" trips, and consolidate many trips into a few more productive trips (when you go to the store, you visit many different places in one trip to get everything done, instead of repeat trips). Now, the elasticity of oil may not be unit elastic, I will conscede this point, but the matter of the issue is that Americans are consuming less and less oil as the price rises, and this trend will not discontinue.
Another property of economics: The longer a trend of price increases continues, the more elastic an item becomes. Basically speaking, oil may be relatively inelastic today, over the course of a week, or over the course of a year, but in the long run... it will become more and more elastic to the point where we may be non-dependant on it entirely. This is due to increased amount of substitute items (public transportation, hybrid cars, solar power, etc...) that comparitively become less expensive, or become available.
|