View Single Post
Unread 12-15-2003, 05:52 PM   #6 (permalink)
Saint DH
Senior Member
 

Join Date: Feb 2002
Posts: 6,150
Internets: 284753
Saint DH has a reputation beyond repute Saint DH has a reputation beyond repute Saint DH has a reputation beyond repute Saint DH has a reputation beyond repute Saint DH has a reputation beyond repute Saint DH has a reputation beyond repute Saint DH has a reputation beyond repute Saint DH has a reputation beyond repute Saint DH has a reputation beyond repute Saint DH has a reputation beyond repute Saint DH has a reputation beyond repute
Post

The French philosopher Blaise Pascal (1623-1662), realizing that all the traditional proofs were inconclusive, asked the question instead, "Since we are all betting our lives, either for or against God, what is the best bet to make?" He concluded that the best bet would be to believe in God. Even if he should not exist, we still experience the immense joy of believing and will lose no more than a few paltry pleasures of the flesh, while if we refuse to believe, we experience at best only a few questionable pleasures but deny ourselves the greatest happiness this life can provide. And if God should exist, then the believer not only knows the joy of belief here but will experience eternal life with God hereafter, while the unbeliever not only misses the blessings of life with God in the present but loses his very soul for all eternity. Belief thus offers the most to gain and the least to lose.

Criticisms
Objectors ask how one can be expected to honestly believe what he/she simply can't believe? If no solid evidence for the existence of the deity can be found, then reason dictates that belief must either be suspended (agnosticism) or denied (atheism). One should not surrender one's intellectual integrity or respect for truth merely for the unsupportable hope of some kind of either earthly or eternal bliss, or both, in case one might be mistaken.

While we're at it, let's discuss the moral argument for the existance of God. One version of this argument, made famous by Immanuel Kant, says that even though good will is the only unconditioned good, justice still requires that good people should be happy and bad people unhappy. But the reverse is all too often the case. Therefore, if morality is to be justified, there must be another life where people will receive their proper rewards and punishments, and if there is such a life, God must be responsible for it. Also, we have an unlimited capacity for moral goodness, yet our lives come to an end long before we have even begun to fulfill this moral potential. Therefore, there must be another life where this capacity can be realized. And if this is so, then there must be a God who is responsible for it. Otherwise, life is unexplaniedly unjust and unfair.

Any thoughts/comments on either of these? If you'd like to hear any of the other types of major arguments for the existance of God, such as the teleological, cosmological, or ontological arguments, and their criticisms just say the word.

[ December 15, 2003, 04:21 PM: Message edited by: Dirty Harry ]
Saint DH is offline   Reply With Quote