First of all: Great idea for a thread! I know I've sampled quite a few beers in my time and will love to contribute.
Now on to the Sam Adams debate:
I am a Sam Adams fan as well. I think it is one of the premier American beers. It doesn't taste like piss like most American pilsners, and the variety they have is impressive.
I killed a few of these last night:
Samuel Adams Black Lager
Very dark, even by Sam Adams standards. A great flavor, reminds me of some Irish beers I've had in the past. The beer is actually thick as well, rather than merely tasting thick (this is not necessarily a good thing). Overall I rate this beer a 7.4/10. B-
[ December 13, 2005, 04:34 PM: Message edited by: DJ FC ]