View Single Post
Unread 11-14-2003, 01:23 AM   #22 (permalink)
Pliedes
Senior Member
 
Pliedes's Avatar
 

Join Date: Oct 2002
Location: Puget Sound
Posts: 4,594
Internets: 1608
Pliedes has a brilliant future Pliedes has a brilliant future Pliedes has a brilliant future Pliedes has a brilliant future Pliedes has a brilliant future Pliedes has a brilliant future Pliedes has a brilliant future Pliedes has a brilliant future Pliedes has a brilliant future Pliedes has a brilliant future Pliedes has a brilliant future

Post

We don't have to pin 9/11 on Iraqi based terrorist to determine that we need to get rid of them.

Would the people under an oppresive dictator be better off if they were liberated by a country who had the power to do so? Moreso, is such an action permissible? There lies the crux of the issue.

I'm gonna build a hypothetical situation for two reasons: 1) Just to get into the foriegn policy issue, which is the heart of the issue, and 2) because I thought up cool names for the countries.

Don't relate it to Iraq and America. Let's make up new countries. Fackengooseland is a super powerful country with influence all over the world. The Fackengoosians live in a republic where people aren't oppressed, in fact, quite the opposite, they participate in the government. Now, the people for Narfital are ruled by a horrible oppresive dictator how mercilessly murders tens of thousands of his own people just to stay in power and build the riches of the elite few.

Now, if the Fackengooses intervene, they will save thousands of lives and ultimately lead to a better life for the Narfitals. But they would be encroaching up Narfitals sovereignity as a nation. So at what point does it become justified for the Fackengooses to help out?
Pliedes is offline   Reply With Quote