View Single Post
Unread 10-30-2006, 11:58 PM   #14 (permalink)
Jake
Senior Member
 

Join Date: Nov 2002
Posts: 148
Internets: 10
Jake is on a distinguished road
Send a message via AIM to Jake
Default

Just thought I’d add my two cents.

I’m a senior studying urban planning at BSU and I’m minoring economics. I have to say I mostly agree with George W. on this one. For anyone who has studied economics they should know that this is a classic case of trying to internalize an externality. Alright then, for those of us who haven’t studied economics what exactly is an externality? Well, an externality is a form of market failure and inefficiency that occurs whenever someone does not pay the full costs or receive the full benefits of a transaction. So what then are the externalities that result from cars? Well there are 2 primary externalities: pollution and congestion. When a car pollutes the air, its driver does not pay for his action of polluting. As a result, the rest of us in society bear the costs of the driver’s action through increased medical costs, less blue skies/ sunny days, global warming etc, regardless of whether we drive. Second, when too many vehicles drive on a highway each vehicle imposes a cost on every other vehicle in the form of lost time. Beebs stated that she believed congestion and pollution to be negligible however, I would disagree with this argument depending on the location. In places like Los Angeles air pollution and traffic congestion are significant, trust me I lived there last summer. I have seen reports that estimate these costs to be in the hundred billions for LA resulting from pollution and congestion. I realize however that these problems are less acute in rural Indiana, though even this is changing.

So the question then is what do we do as a result of these externalities? Well economists since the 1920’s have agreed that government intervention into the market as a result of externalities is necessary. Now this doesn’t necessarily just mean soviet (liberal) styled command and control government intervention from the 1950’s…. no no no…..Today’s economists like to use government intervention through the use of market based solution. There are two well-respected forms of internalizing externalities that economists like. The first is the privatization of the afflicted resource (air and roads). However, this represents a real problem in this case because well…. how do you sell off the sky, and second selling off roads leads to monopoly power which represents another form of market failure. The second and better option then is what is called a Pigouvian tax. A Pigouvian tax is when a government enacts a tax on the person generating an externality that is equal to the cost he/she imposes on society. This has many effects. It gives people who generate these externalities incentive to do drive less, find ways to reduce their externalities and compensates society so that they can A: clean the air, or B: invest in greater road capacity or mass transit.

Alright then, so all of this points to what “W” is talking about in raising the national gas tax right? Well, partially but not exactly, there are two problems. First, the issue that Beeb’s raised, that these problems might vary by location. Since these problems vary by location it is logical that LA might need a $3 tax while rural Indiana only needs a .20 cent tax. Therefore, instead of setting a national gas tax what we really need is a localized gas tax that varies as the externalities vary in intensity. But some of you might say HA GOOD LUCK none of these local places are willing going to impose a tax on themselves so how the hell are you going to get them to? Well then what we need then is federal prodding to force localities to set up these local taxes and tie it to transportation funding. Those communities that enact there local gas tax and have hard evidence that there tax level equals the cost of the externality receive transportation funding while those communities that do not risk losing transportation funding. This is a common practice with regard to air quality and seems to work well. The second and final problem is the political problem expressed by f3lix, which sparked my interest in writing this response. PEOPLE DON’T LIKE NEW TAXES!!!! Alright then your right no new taxes!! So then make the tax neutral! A neutral tax is when you raise the taxes in one area but you reduce taxes in others. Therefore, raise the gas tax but offset this by reducing income taxes or property taxes. Therefore peoples tax bill remains the same but at the same time they also are forced to realize the true costs of using an automobile.

This is no longer about conservative or liberal. This is about educated versus non-educated! I get tired of everyone’s ideologies (on both sides of the spectrum) getting in the way of progress. People need to put their stupid ass dogma’s aside and start using their brains or at least try to consider something new. In conclusion, if you always do what you’ve always done, you’ll always get what you’ve always got!!

Phewww… that was a lot of writing! Thanks to those who actually read it! Definitely, my longest post on Nubblies yet, but hey I’m on fall break, had nothing better to do, and care greatly about topics such as these regarding urbanism.
Jake is offline   Reply With Quote