Very good comment f3lix and I also share your concerns about taxes not being repealed after the problem is alleviated but there are also ways to deal with this problem which I wish to address. First, in all honesty I would not try to deal with the problem of congestion through the use of a gas tax. I would only use the gas tax to deal with air pollution... here’s why. Air pollution is a regional problem, which can be dealt with in the ways I discussed in my previous post. However, congestion is something that is very localized. It is possible in a single community or even neighborhood to have on street that is heavily congested and another, which is virtually empty. Therefore, it is unfair to bundle in the costs of congestion into a gas tax (which everyone who drives must pay) because not everyone contributes to congestion equally. Only those who use the congested streets contribute to congestion and should be required to compensate. To this end there are several new ways to deal with congestion other than an unfair gas tax to solve congestion, which may also allay your fears of the tax never being repealed. The main idea is the use of a congestion charge or congestion toll, which have successfully been implemented in London, Stockholm, Singapore, and parts of Southern California. Congestion tolls work like this….. The government sets a standard for a street or highway… say 45 mph. As more and more cars load onto the road contributing to congestion and slowing down traffic the toll to use the road increases. This provides incentives for drivers not to use congested roads during peak periods and also provides the government with revenue to invest in new capacity. However, this brings us back to the place we were before of having a tax. So how does this system self regulate itself so that as the problem is alleviated so to is the tax. Well as the number of drivers decreases as a result of the increased toll or from increased capacity and the speed of traffic raises back to 45 mph or above the toll decreases. If traffic speed exceeds 45 mph its possible that the toll may even drop to 0! This is a great system because the price varies as the problem varies. Most of the existing systems have prices that are updated by the minute and use electronic devices to collect the fees from drivers so that you don’t have to slow down to a toll plaza and get out your change!!! So this system is self-correcting and doesn’t require much political oversight, which is nice.
However, that still leaves us with the problem of the gas tax used for air pollution after the problem has been solved. For this I can only rely on the promise of democracy. This is sometimes the greatness of the two party system and well to be honest fiscally responsible republicans. I know for a fact those pesky republicans and libertarians, whether I agree with them or not, are always looking for ways to cut taxes, which in all honesty is probably good for all of us. The great thing about democracy is that however imperfect it may be it does represent some sort of choice and competition! Ps.. last time I checked I remember George W pushing through a whole series of large tax cuts. Therefore, however imperfect America may be there is always hope my pessimistic friend.
For myself I try to avoid identifying with either of the 2 major parities. I believe both parties can do great good and harm depending on the situation and context of their actions. Obviously democrats and government intervention is more necessary in large cities where people’s actions greatly impact one another and market failures are all abound. And vice versa for republicans and small town America. Plus I very much believe there are great conservatives and great liberals, and horrible conservatives and horrible liberals. I just get tired when either party’s dogma gets in the way. Conservatives tend to naively believe the market to be perfect and liberals tend to believe the market to be an evil device, which perpetuates injustice. I however believe both have good things to say at times so long as we listen reason and not ideology. Final thought….. Revolutions start with an idea and end when the only idea left is clinging to power. Some words of wisdom for both parties.
|