Thread: WATCHMEN.
View Single Post
Unread 03-16-2009, 04:37 PM   #46 (permalink)
TwoBlackEyes
Been told twice
 
TwoBlackEyes's Avatar
 

Join Date: Jan 2009
Posts: 312
Internets: 1299
TwoBlackEyes has much to be proud of TwoBlackEyes has much to be proud of TwoBlackEyes has much to be proud of TwoBlackEyes has much to be proud of TwoBlackEyes has much to be proud of TwoBlackEyes has much to be proud of TwoBlackEyes has much to be proud of TwoBlackEyes has much to be proud of TwoBlackEyes has much to be proud of
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by THEINCREDIBLEdork View Post
I finally saw it tonight. It was bad, really bad. I especially hate how they didn't give you any sense of the old school masked avengers except through a crappy montage at the beginning of the movie (wtf who puts a montage at the beginning of a movie?). It was unnecessarily long which was expected but they left all the cool shit out and just over styled crap with long music sequences, the soundtrack was almost comical sometimes, the majority of the lines delivered came off extremely cheesy, how horrible were the prison scenes?, etc etc
Uh, have you ever read the graphic novel?

Cause the old school avengers got basically the exact same treatment in the movie as they did in the book, where we learned about them almost exclusively in flashbacks and clippings (from Under the Hood and other sources). They didn't play an active role in the main plot of the book any more than they did in the movie. They did skip over the murder of Hollis Mason, but there is an hour of additional material that was cut that will be released on the DVD.

Also the "cheesy" lines were almost exclusively straight from the book, verbatim. Including the "who would want a cowboy president" bit at the end.

I agree that the soundtrack was a bit distracting, but at least one song (all along the watchtower) is also straight out of the book. And once you've committed to using period music to set scenes, you've got to do it all, or it just makes it more jarring when the one song happens. And using song lyrics to parallel what is happening on screen actually hearkens back to the parallel imagery between the Tales of the Black Freighter and what the heroes are doing at the same time.

The montage was fucking amazing, btw. Almost shot by shot from the book, showing the evolutions of the masked heroes from their height of popularity to their fall from grace to their eventual move to the shadows (Rorschach was PERFECT).

Basically, I can't imagine how anyone could claim to like the novel and NOT like this movie. It's the closest thing that could possibly have been done to bring it to life. Even changing the squid plotline into the S.Q.U.I.D project was a stroke of genius. It works BETTER than the original plot because it furthered the theme of Dr. Manhattan as God (the Watchmaker), who in this case became a vengeful god demanding an end to hostilities. The squid would only scare the world for so long before tensions arose again. THe idea of the world being destroyed by an angry superman (even if he IS american) means that there's no more temptation by governments to even try going to war. They can't assume that the fallout will leave the midwest untouched, the way they could under MAD scenarios. When you piss off a GOD, he fucks you completely.

Anyway, great movie, and I'm totally buying the DVD for the extra footage, plus the Tales of the Black Freighter.
TwoBlackEyes is offline   Reply With Quote