(second god damn time i wrote this, much shorter, my laptop sux)
Yes, I have read the graphic novel. And a movie is an entirely different medium than a comic book. And when you confine yourself to following the comic exactly all of the nuances of the comic were all lost. It ended up with a film with lots of "stuff" that didn't fit well at all together.
I didn't say the lines were cheesy, I said they came off cheesy. A lot of things that worked in the comic came off as cheesy. for example, the scene where Nite Owl cracks Ozy's password literally made me squirm in my chair it was so bad.
The movie does not stand on its own.
The one shining performance I can say there was is Rorschach, his last scene was awesome. but all the characters come off as cliche cutouts.
Unfortunately the only thing thats going to save this movie from being remembered as a complete crapshoot are fanboi's with rose colored glasses and a shit-ton of hype.
Dark Knight > Iron Man > Xmen 2 > batman begins > spiderman > hulk 2 > watchmen
|