Thread: WATCHMEN.
View Single Post
Unread 03-16-2009, 07:07 PM   #55 (permalink)
TwoBlackEyes
Been told twice
 
TwoBlackEyes's Avatar
 

Join Date: Jan 2009
Posts: 312
Internets: 1299
TwoBlackEyes has much to be proud of TwoBlackEyes has much to be proud of TwoBlackEyes has much to be proud of TwoBlackEyes has much to be proud of TwoBlackEyes has much to be proud of TwoBlackEyes has much to be proud of TwoBlackEyes has much to be proud of TwoBlackEyes has much to be proud of TwoBlackEyes has much to be proud of
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by DDTempest View Post
Really the thing that made the movie not sit well with me was the loss of the nuances included in the graphic novel. The details and intricacy made Watchmen the masterpiece that it is. The movie pulls out the basic concept and does it well. Metaphorically its like baking a cake and only putting frosting on the top of it. Sure its cake and cake is good, but it would be a lot better if it had frosting all over, sprinkles, and a clever message written in more frosting on top.

Perhaps try watching it again. There are a LOT of little things in there that you might miss the first time through. But basically some of it comes down to the fact that there was no way to cram all of that novel into just 2.5 hours. If the general public was willing to sit through 5 hours of movie, they might have been able to come close. But you can't READ Watchmen in 3 hours, let alone film it all, unless you want to miss a whole huge chunk of the action.

I just think it did a damn fine job of staying surprisingly true to the source material considering the limitations.

The one change that DID piss me off was the new 2nd silk spectre costume. Why the fuck change it from what it was in the book. NO REASON. It didn't even look that good on her. Her tits were all wonky looking in the new thing.
TwoBlackEyes is offline   Reply With Quote