View Single Post
Unread 05-18-2010, 12:46 AM   #786 (permalink)
Mr. Blonde
Spice Master
 
Mr. Blonde's Avatar
 

Join Date: Jan 2004
Posts: 17,969
Internets: 284106
Mr. Blonde has a reputation beyond repute Mr. Blonde has a reputation beyond repute Mr. Blonde has a reputation beyond repute Mr. Blonde has a reputation beyond repute Mr. Blonde has a reputation beyond repute Mr. Blonde has a reputation beyond repute Mr. Blonde has a reputation beyond repute Mr. Blonde has a reputation beyond repute Mr. Blonde has a reputation beyond repute Mr. Blonde has a reputation beyond repute Mr. Blonde has a reputation beyond repute
Default

Firstly, I plan on keeping this discussion civil and intellectual, even if other members don't.

I'm surprised he provided scriptures you haven't read yet, honestly. I would suggest you read the entire Bible, cover to cover ASAP as soon as you finish this book. There is very little logic imo in basing your entire life on a book you haven't read voraciously. I got a good overview of the Bible in church during most of my life, but I haven't read the whole thing yet; something I plan to do after I get back from my trip is buy one (as well as a Qur'an) and read them.

Either way, you should thank UB for the book suggestion. I have only read a lot of Sam Harris' articles and watched a lot of his videos online, but have not seen the book yet (remember, I didn't have any short books to suggest ---but I will read it soon). Being as I haven't read it, he may be better equipped to discuss some of the aspects of the book than myself, but there are some parts of your post I want to address.

Quote:
I can relate to a lot of what he says and furthermore I agree with it. Especially when he talks about "christian liberals" or "christian moderate". There is no fence riding, either you believe and follow Christ or you don't.
This is something i've been thinking about a lot, lately. About how people are so quick to label themselves Christians, yet engage in quite illicit behaviors, at least from the Bibles point of view, such as (most commonly) premarital sex and crime (studies have all been relatively the same basically, but I just found lists nonreligious inmates at only about 20%, the rest being religiously affiliated, Christian or not -- It's important to remember my beef is with all religion, not just Christianity.)

How come Christians get to participate in illicit behaviors, notably and in you case premarital sex, then still get to sit in their moral high horse by calling themselves Christians and ask for forgiveness? It's been proposed that the nonreligious are generally MORE moral than religious, as they recognize their duty to other humans, when the religious just have to ask forgiveness after they screw somebody over.


Quote:
Proverbs 3:5 can better explain where I'm coming from on this "Trust in the LORD with all your heart and lean not on your own understanding." If this was the case these people are doing the opposite. They are leaning on their own understanding or in essence putting there self above God. Pride and self-reliance is a sin that I feel is very prevalent in our faith. Some of these people may have the salvation of Christ but they are yet to know him because they don't pursue him through his word and teachings. They do not trust in God with all their heart but they rather lean on what their own understanding of something is.
There is a bit I disagree with here, firstly: Why are you so hesitant to attribute the great things man has accomplished to a god? Where is this need to prostrate, beg and abjectness coming from? There is nothing wrong with pride and self-reliance IMO. I'm doing pretty well with it.

"They do not trust in God with all their heart but thy rather lean on what their own understanding of something is" -- Isn't this what preachers and priests do on a regular basis? What gives them a higher moral or subjective interpretation than anybody else? Do you seriously believe in the infallibility of, say, the Pope, or even your pastor? The huge amount of Christian demoninations alone immediately casts doubt on allusion that Christians shouldn't be allowed to interpret the Bible how they wish. Who is? Where does that authority come from?

Quote:
Harris brings up a lot of OT scriptures which 5 or 6,000 years ago related better to that historical context.
An omniscient god can see the future.

Quote:
Scripture meant nothing to me before I was a believer. Now that I read with eyes of faith scripture has a whole new meaning to me.
I wouldn't say scripture means nothing to me, nor would any atheist with his head screwed on right. It of course has it's value, as i've stated in understanding the historical mindsets and happenings of our ancestors and developing humanity. It has a new meaning to you because you WANT it to and you're surrounded by people who are not dissenting. It's a logical fallacy called argumentum ad consequentiam and it's widely used in religion (among many other things) and the basis of my current signature. We all have emotions and things we want to be true, but the simple fact of the matter, as an intelligent and mature species, is that to progress we have to be true to our intellects, not our slavish emotions.

Quote:
Harris can't comprehend or accept certain things because he hasn't yet received the gift of faith.
BDH, faith is not a virtue. I know Christianity wants you to think it is, no, NEEDS you to think it is in order to exist, but it's simply not. Faith is tantamount to ignorance, or at the very best refusal to acknowledge something you know about. Forcefully pushing it in the back of your head and not paying it any credence, but you're a smart guy, and that feeling is not going to go away. This is a passage from "god is not Great", by Christopher Hitchens that I just read yesterday:

"If one must have faith in order to believe something, or believe IN something, then the likelihood of that something having any truth or value is considerably diminished. The harder work of inquiry, proof, and demonstration is infinitely more rewarding, and has confronted us with findings far more "miraculous" and "transcendent" than any theology."

Psychedelics are illegal not because a loving government is concerned that you may jump out of a third story window. Psychedelics are illegal because they dissolve opinion structures and culturally laid down models of behavior and information processing.

― Terence McKenna
Mr. Blonde is offline   Reply With Quote