Ya, after watching the show with Tits, we both thought that the end, after-the-credits picture (of the wreckage with zero activity around) meant that they all died on the plane and the island was simply them wandering around as spirits not knowing wtf to do.
After reading other peoples' theories, though, it seems that the prevailing thought is that everything that happened on the island was absolutely real, and that the island itself is absolutely real. Everything in flash sideways segments occurred after the person had died on the island and it was their spirit trying to make amends with the shit that troubled them during life (jack's daddy issues, kate's guilt for killing her dad, Sawyer trying to find Sawyer, Jin Vs. Sun's dad, John's paralysis...etc). So all of that shit was like a purgatory of sorts.
The weird shit is that, for some reason, Desmond could switch consciousness between the two places. Because of this, he was the first one to realize wtf was going on and then started to find others in the purgatory place. By touching one another or an item from the island, they would remember all of their time on the island and realize that, even though they were fuck-asses in real life, their time on the island led them to develop as people to the point where everything in their life was settled and they were ready to cross over to the real afterlife.
The end of the show was simply showing Jack's specific journey. He died after saving the island. The flash sideways that were going on were all actually occurring chronologically after he closed his eyes for the final time (final scene before credits). His dad told him that many had come before him and many would be after, some long after. This explains those that got off the island in the plane still showing up in the church.
In short: My original theory was "hmm, they were dead the whole time". This other theory is a shitload more deep and really makes more sense, so I'm inclined to go with it.
|