Thread: Birth Control
View Single Post
Unread 06-30-2011, 10:56 PM   #13 (permalink)
Mr. Blonde
Spice Master
 
Mr. Blonde's Avatar
 

Join Date: Jan 2004
Posts: 17,969
Internets: 284106
Mr. Blonde has a reputation beyond repute Mr. Blonde has a reputation beyond repute Mr. Blonde has a reputation beyond repute Mr. Blonde has a reputation beyond repute Mr. Blonde has a reputation beyond repute Mr. Blonde has a reputation beyond repute Mr. Blonde has a reputation beyond repute Mr. Blonde has a reputation beyond repute Mr. Blonde has a reputation beyond repute Mr. Blonde has a reputation beyond repute Mr. Blonde has a reputation beyond repute
Default

It depends on whether or not you want to call the historical difference in height a significant change, on terms of survival capability.

What is the world average for height? What are you comparing it to?

You could, of course, possibly be right, but one would have to put forth a solid argument on two different fronts:

* Whether height is mostly a result of sexual selection or natural selection. If it has to do with sexual selection (which I would wager it does, as being a few inches taller would not be what I would call a significant change, compared to something like the development of teeth, to one's survival ability), I don't think that quite matters in regard to birth birth control, which was your original question.


* How do we know recent height differences are an evolutionary development at all and not something that is already "hard wired" (by past evolutionary changes) into our genes with a better diet and lifestyle? Easy example, if you look at many older Koreans, who were around for the Korean war or in the generation after it, you will see that many of them have a very small stature. But once Korea became modernized and on it's way to being "first world" in the 70's, you can see almost immediately the change in just one generation. That, by very definition, is not evolution, but it is definitely a phenotype that I think would be worth studying.


I'm not saying you're wrong, but this is one of the reasons why evolutionary biology (and evolutionary psychology) are such difficult and controversial fields...the HUGE number of variables that go into figuring things like this out. Really fun to think about, though.
Mr. Blonde is offline   Reply With Quote