Man face is probably somebody's grandma by now. The pics I could find after gaz's covers thumbnails was here:
My favorite P**h*** Pets - Page 98 - Vintage Erotica Forums . Granted this was on an iPhone and mostly profile shots and no close up faces where I could see a "maybe, but not sure," after the NSFW pictures, there's not much doubt it's not her. This chick is 99.9% not Carol Harrison.
I've also been trying to get more info from Scott, but he says he never saw the pictures and that it was after she graduated from high school, thus eliminating Shawntai as the pseudonym. I've asked another friend "Kurt" who used to live by her and was kinda friends with her but not really close. He says he never heard anything about this and that Carol lived at home until about age 20 then got married/preggers and then moved away. Hasn't heard from her since then. I'm still leaning on the whole thing is bullshit.