Hmm...I don't see any black text, so I assume you're serious.
Size and population-wise, perhaps they are similar. Everything else wise? Certainly not.
Compare: Economy Muncie, IN - Fishers, IN is a great resource to show this.
Muncie's avg household income is $28k for Christ sake, about a third of Fishers. This is probably why the violent crime is 3x and property crime 6x in Muncie versus Fishers, perhaps caused by the unemployment rate being 50% higher in Muncie.
I'm not in the business of saying Fishers is the best place in the world to live. I'm not here to put it on a pedestal at all. But saying it's like Muncie? A bold claim, sir.