Thread: #Occupy
View Single Post
Unread 11-17-2011, 11:29 PM   #187 (permalink)
Beebs
Poor Sport
 
Beebs's Avatar
 

Join Date: Feb 2004
Location: Indianapolis / Middlebury / Long Lake
Posts: 5,306
Internets: 127341
Beebs has a reputation beyond repute Beebs has a reputation beyond repute Beebs has a reputation beyond repute Beebs has a reputation beyond repute Beebs has a reputation beyond repute Beebs has a reputation beyond repute Beebs has a reputation beyond repute Beebs has a reputation beyond repute Beebs has a reputation beyond repute Beebs has a reputation beyond repute Beebs has a reputation beyond repute
Send a message via AIM to Beebs
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Repugnant Abomination View Post
It's skewed though, isn't it? Since corporations are composed of people (who know doubt have divergent views), how is it that corporations can vote and or lobby with one voice? That's my main problem with it. It goes from the top down. It's fine for corporations to act in their own best interest business wise, in terms of profits and what not, but when they deliberately get involved in politics you have a small number of people wielding too much power and influence, because they have the entire corporation behind them - when a lot of times a large number of people who make up that corporation don't agree with its policies.
I was more just clearing up the debate, but since you asked; I don't think it's much of an agency dilemma because there is sort of an implied consent when you take ownership of a corporation. You also have a vote within the corporation, and the ultimate option to sell your stake.

I can certainly see the argument that it makes a donating corporation powerful, but I think a corporation shouldn't be less able to contribute than other types of groups of people.

Also an issue comes up when there is a majority shareholder, especially of a small corporation, although obviously he can donate as a single person.

While people might not like all of the side effects that came with the Citizens United ruling, the root of the issue of campaign as free speech is a very real one, and limits on how much money people can spend in that speech are incredibly dangerous.

I think the effort should, and would be more effectively, be placed at the feet of the elected politicians; hold them accountable to make sure they are not a puppet. In the end, a vote is the only actual vote, although money spent is undeniable a huge part of getting votes.
Beebs is offline   Reply With Quote