View Single Post
Unread 11-18-2011, 12:50 AM   #1 (permalink)
Beebs
Poor Sport
 
Beebs's Avatar
 

Join Date: Feb 2004
Location: Indianapolis / Middlebury / Long Lake
Posts: 5,306
Internets: 127341
Beebs has a reputation beyond repute Beebs has a reputation beyond repute Beebs has a reputation beyond repute Beebs has a reputation beyond repute Beebs has a reputation beyond repute Beebs has a reputation beyond repute Beebs has a reputation beyond repute Beebs has a reputation beyond repute Beebs has a reputation beyond repute Beebs has a reputation beyond repute Beebs has a reputation beyond repute
Send a message via AIM to Beebs
Default Tim Tebow: What the hell is going on?

The guy seems to prove both his doubters and supporters right at the same time.

On one hand he clearly is not very good at the things modern quarterbacks are judged on. He doesn't complete enough passes, and he just generally doesn't work as a QB in most playbooks.

On the other hand, does he need to be a good QB in the modern sense to be a good player? Going way back, the QB was just one of 3 or 4 backs, they wouldn't always or even usually be the one taking the snap. In the NFL, nothing works long term, the game constantly ebbs and flows, so if this continues to win games, why not keep running it?

If he doesn't need to be a modern QB, what about other freak athletes who played QB at some point? How successful would a similar offense be by moving somebody like Matt Jones, who was an absolute freak at Arkansas (although he loved him some cocaine), or Brad Smith? What about high school QBs? Micheal Bush, Anquan Boldin, Hines Ward? I know Tom Zbikowski played as an option QB before going to Notre Dame and took a handful of snaps there. How would they do?

I don't think the "he's going to get hurt" argument holds much water; if he gets hurt you just throw in a backup QB who is more orthodox.

It's very interesting.
Beebs is offline   Reply With Quote