Quote:
Originally Posted by Mr. Blonde
Why not? One could easily say that the GOP lineup is full of comedians. Let's not forget Al Franken, a Senator from Minnesota.
|
Quote:
|
I get where you're coming from RE: corporate responsibility, but that's about it. I refuse to accept money=speech and as long as you insist on supporting it I don't see how you are intellectually okay with saying "No, comedians should not be allowed a political voice...but racist, backwards-ass creationist war mongering hicks should be allowed a political voice as much as their money can get them.
|
I'm not really saying that money = speech. I'm saying that entities have a right to state their view, and I'm saying that they should be able to collect and spend their money freely. The most urgent purpose of freedom of speech is to protect political speech, which is what PACs do; they express a political viewpoint. It makes no sense to have free speech but then make an exception for what is a group specifically dedicated to political speech and say "you have to stay within these special boundaries that don't exist for other topics or other groups of people because it might effect our political system." That is what it is supposed to do, that is our system: speaking out about ideas. By saying "well it's not fair that some groups spend more than others" that is equating money with speech, because it is saying money spent is more important than the message.
Quote:
|
Also, why in the FUCK does the US not have a "factchecking/truth" law in order for our fucking national media, ESPECIALLY when it comes to political reporting? The fact that any of our networks can blatantly lie to tens or hundreds of millions of people at once is INSANE. Is it that considered censorship? Why isn't political reporting (honest mistakes/public apologies aside) held to the some form of civilian perjury?
|
This is a pretty surprising question, honestly. There are slander and libel laws for lies with intent to harm, not sure what else you want? What is "truth", and according to whom? What about parody, that is, in simple terms, dishonest, but was rightly ruled as protected (Larry Flynt). Reporters aren't under oath, for one thing. I'm really pretty surprised at this section; what exactly do you find wrong here? Outside of math, there really aren't any fields where everybody can agree on what is true and what isn't. You can stop people from maliciously lying already. What you seem to be wanting is a ban on opinion, or at least opinions other than your own.
Quote:
|
And I'm not just talking about money being used for media endorsements here. I'm talking about the back-alley, unwritten deals that this money buys. Lobbying = political favors. Media backing candidates = political favors.
|
What is the answer though? Making it illegal to talk to politicians? Illegal to donate and talk? Illegal to spend money on a viewpoint? The only reasonable way to stop it is through not electing politicians who can be bought, and obviously continuing to make bribery illegal. All lobbying really is though, is people speaking their minds to somebody with the power to do something about it.
Quote:
In no way do I feel the same deification (and rewriting of history that goes along with that) of the founding fathers that the Tea party and Neo-cons do. But I have read enough to know that most of them were smarter than any of us here, and certainly smarter than most of the presidential candidates.
If they were alive today, given a brush up of the past 240 years, and saw the almost-oligarchy government and insane amount of debt to foreign countries/federal reserve we have going on the States today, honestly Beebs, what position do you think they would take?
|
Free speech really isn't the same as something like the second amendment though, you can't argue it applies to a different time and what have you; free speech is a pretty universal ideal, it's in the UN charter for human rights. I don't think you need to have any particular esteem for the constitution to argue for free speech.
It's an interesting question; they were a pretty varied group, more so than thought of today. On one hand I think they would be appalled at the scale and scope of government control, on the other one of the first things our government ever did was take out a loan from foreign governments to pay for the revolution.