The hebrew kind of brings up an issue me and the other coach are dealing with; to what degree do you assign kids a position vs teaching them as many positions as possible. It's sort of a smaller part of the larger question of how important is winning? Obviously winning isn't really the end goal at u12, but the kids obviously have more fun winning than losing, and are smart enough to realize what their best team is.
The part I'm especially dealing with is goalkeepers, we don't really have any on either team, a few have played there, but none would consider themselves a goalie. The last thing I want to do is make somebody who doesn't want to play goalie a lot, and even if I do find a few that like it, I don't want to limit their development for the other positions.
Personally I played goalie in the first organized game I ever played and never really left; that helped me in a lot of ways but also had some disadvantages. Mainly I stopped growing at 5'7" in middle school, so was always the shortest keeper I knew, it's not a huge deal, but high level keepers tend to be around 6' tall, with 1 exception I can think of. On the other hand if you always think of yourself as a keeper, but still do a lot of drills meant for outfield players, you transfer those skills back to the keeper position easier than if you split time between positions; my best quality as I got older was my ability to play with my feet, which was important as one of the first generations of keepers to grow up with the passback rule.
So hopefully I can develop at least 1 girl per team who enjoys playing keeper but is able to comfortably play elsewhere, and 1 per team who can be an emergency backup who is comfortable enough in goal to get by. Longer term if you get 2 keepers close together in age, it's going to be an issue when they get to high school that they can't both be the starter.
|