Quote:
Originally Posted by Mr. Blonde
Sorry Repug but you are just spouting apologist nonsense. I wonder what your intentions were digging this up in the first place. Yes, movies and pretty much everything else can be oversimplified. It's called a summary. And summaries are by very definition the most brief and correct overview of a subject. Sorry I can't get all Aquinas with you.
|
How does pointing out that you can oversimplify a work of fiction make me an apologist? You said something questionable and I pointed it out. What you were doing was not summarizing, it was caricaturing. And oversimplifying.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Mr. Blonde
So we're going by "what many thoughtful Christians are saying" now? Whatever moderate/liberate religious school of thought is in the present is how things go in the afterlife? This is the fundamental problem with religion -- endless interpretation.
|
Yes, thoughtful Christians. You always write with fundamentalists in mind. There are plenty of those. But there are also more nuanced, intelligent people who practice branches of Christianity that embrace science and have a non-literal interpretation of stories in the Bible they consider allegorical, like Genesis.
Furthermore, what's wrong with endless interpretation? There are many subjects outside of theology that are endlessly debated and interpreted: literary theory, philosophy, law, etc...
Quote:
Originally Posted by Mr. Blonde
Let me rephrase for you:
Somebody can actually go out and experiment with crime, fornication, and drugs, and still come back, empty and hollow inside like the rest of us, with open arms to a religion they think will complete them, and they often convince themselves that it has. (CONVINCE IS A KEYWORD HERE)
|
People convince themselves of things every day even outside religion. We've all probably convinced ourselves we're better people than we really are.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Mr. Blonde
I have always realized the silliness in, say, a serial murder-rapist asking for forgiveness, MEANING IT, on his deathbed and being granted it.
|
In the context of an all knowing, all loving God, why is that silly? I think you're viewing that scenario through a human perspective. Perhaps some things are unforgivable to a person, but that's not what we're talking about here.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Mr. Blonde
I bet that feels so good; to experience many of the "sins" of the world and once you have tired of it, still be able to convince yourself you are loved by a god and then pretend like you're pious. No wonder Christianity is so popular.
|
I think a lot of Christians would say it doesn't feel good at all. I bet a lot would say they feel ashamed by cheating on their husband, stealing from their neighbor, or murdering that stranger for money. But that they're also grateful beyond words and completely humbled by a God that could actually forgive them for it if they are sincere and changed. Honestly, your examples are so oversimplified, dripping with disdain and sarcastic that it's hard to seriously engage you without thinking it's a waste of time.