View Single Post
Unread 12-23-2012, 03:09 AM   #1352 (permalink)
Repugnant Abomination
Almost there...
 
Repugnant Abomination's Avatar
 

Join Date: Feb 2005
Posts: 5,979
Internets: 164547
Repugnant Abomination has a reputation beyond repute Repugnant Abomination has a reputation beyond repute Repugnant Abomination has a reputation beyond repute Repugnant Abomination has a reputation beyond repute Repugnant Abomination has a reputation beyond repute Repugnant Abomination has a reputation beyond repute Repugnant Abomination has a reputation beyond repute Repugnant Abomination has a reputation beyond repute Repugnant Abomination has a reputation beyond repute Repugnant Abomination has a reputation beyond repute Repugnant Abomination has a reputation beyond repute
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Mr. Blonde View Post
Hello my little lost children. I had a nice hiatus.

I came here to say that Repug, having posted a video between Sam Harris and Dr. Lane Craig, probably the most dishonest religious apologist master debater of all time, is proof that Repugnant Abomination has become a religious apologist in full.
I posted that clip not because I agree with Dr. Lane Craig, but because Sam Harris was so completely owned simply because he could not stick to the premise of the debate. That tends to be your problem too, ironically, making "debating" you a maddening waste of time. But no, I'm sad to report I am not a religious apologist.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Mr. Blonde View Post

Repugnant Abomination is still not likely to admit this to himself. Personally, I would like this confession from him; it would be less cowardly than to hide in the grey curtains of philosophy and not take a stand for what he currently believes in.
Admit what? That I don't know? That I'm open to multiple epistemological paths of knowledge, even though I freely admit none are quite as satisfying as empiricism?

Quote:
Originally Posted by Mr. Blonde View Post
A minor psych evaluation is in order here. I am disappointed that I have to bring up a rather hurtful point of his past, but most of us here know about about Repug's family issues, the great loss he suffered, and the religious insanity he has been put through in the past with his fundamentalist blood relatives.

This, of course, spurred Repug down the path of the militant atheist, which he kept up for a few years. As this wiley, intellectual rebel was tamed by a young female who he recently decided to marry (another major life event that likely brought to life a certain ignored spirituality), he began to think himself all the more of the armchair philosopher.
Yeah, I suffered a great loss, and sure, my family has some odd religious beliefs, and yes, this did lead me to question life more than I ever did before. But I became an atheist because I was emotional--angry, more than anything. It made sense at the time but in retrospect was too simplistic. That's not to say atheism is too simplistic, but rather the way in which I arrived at it was. But you're way off in equating marriage with a "taming" of my intellect. She's challenged my ways of thinking since we met and has been agnostic since I've known her. You've always looked negatively on relationships, as if they somehow make you weak, and I think that's a mistake.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Mr. Blonde View Post

Repug currently resides in a rather poetic realm of spiritual purgatory. He is more afraid of death than he would ever admit publicly, and this fear now rules his life and his worldview. He is convinced that there has to be some sort of higher power in the universe because this fear of dying is so strong in him.
Gosh, I always learn so much about myself from a Mr. Blonde post. Please tell me more aout myself.

I've never been shy about my fear of death, privately or publicly. All you're doing here is smearing my character, rather than my arguments, the true sign of a weak debater.


Quote:
Originally Posted by Mr. Blonde View Post
It's so strong that it has caused him to eschew physical evidence in regard to this higher power (or lack thereof) entirely, based on his comments in this thread. I have already tried to tell him that anything that affects the physical world (as a deity would have to do) would (eventually) be able to be detected by physical instruments, thus falling under the realm of physical science.

Repug has made it clear that he disagrees with this entirely, and that philosophy is the only thing that can answer god questions, which is rather silly, as we are, after all, merely high-thinking apes.
Rationalism is not the only way to answer the God question, it's one way to. It can be used to try and prove or disprove God. A lot of smart men have attempted both. You keep trying to define me but you keep failing, because all you're doing is cutting down a dumb-downed version of me that exists only in your head.


Quote:
Originally Posted by Mr. Blonde View Post
Repug will likely refute the idea that he is an apologist, or that he now believes in a higher power, preferring to hide behind the repeated claims of "I'm just saying that SCIENCE doesn't have all the answers!!! I'm not saying there is a god, I'm just saying, YOU NEVER KNOW, GUYS and also I don't believe atheism is the correct position anymore, which would, by default, make me a form of theist.
Apologist can be a confusing term, because it sounds like you're apologizing for something. The real definition is someone who argues in defense of something controversial. By that definition it sounds like we both are. But with how you're using the term I'd say neither of us are. You just seem to get stuck on the fact that if someone doesn't agree with you not only are they wrong, but they are a God worshiping, science denying creationist. It really does just seem to be a lack of clear, critical thinking on your part, which is why I'm more exasperated than anything else. I think that the fundamental position you're taking is probably correct, from a probability standpoint, but the way in which you've gotten there is rather shallow.


Quote:
Originally Posted by Mr. Blonde View Post
It does not really bother me what Repug, or really anyone believes, as much, anymore, due to an experience I will relate elsewhere. I almost pity Repug, in a very Thomas Aquinas way, because of the absolutely rationally indefensible position of theists everywhere, the religious apologists have such a larger burden to bear, and have to do so much more work to try and make square pegs fit into circle holes. This will always happen when you believe in something emotionally so much, that you desperately claw your way around intellectually to make the worldview you want to adequately fit within the parameters of actual, observable, reality.
I pity this imaginary Repug too But you really shouldn't knock emotional people, since you're probably the most emotionally volatile person I know.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Mr. Blonde View Post
TL;DR - Repug is now a religious apologist who believes in a higher power because: philosophy. He in this way chosen to align himself only with pro-theism philosophers and seems to completely ignore the many atheistic or agnostic philosophers and the points they have made. He no longer has any regard for physical evidence (or lack thereof) in regard to "the god question", and, I should also note, he has not responded to my messages on Facebook to attempt to bridge this belief gap and put it behind us. Thus, sadly, Repug and I can no longer be friends. He is married, well on his way to being a believer, and quite clearly thinks that Nubblites are not "on his level", although he will probably deny this as well.
Oh the webs you have spun. I was pretty hurt when you deleted me, but honestly, it's probably for the best. You are such an emotional person that it's exhausting dealing with your outburst and overwhelming negativity towards most things. Your life sounds like a total wreck 85% of the time and I think it's pretty clear at this point you're dealing with some mental health, or at the very least emotional health issues. I hope you get it together, but in the meantime I think I'm okay with our new status quo.
Repugnant Abomination is offline   Reply With Quote