Quote:
Originally Posted by Repugnant Abomination
The position as it stands right now: God created the universe. God had to exist outside of the universe to create it. The existence of God cannot be confirmed by science and the empirical method if he exists outside of his creation (i.e. space and time).
|
This is the (a?) ontological argument right? a priori attempt at proving God's existence?
---
Empirical evidence for the distinction of desire and pleasure
Quote:
|
Much more recent research (Berridge & Kringelbach, 2010) suggests that earlier scientists had leaped too far in their conclusions. These scientists have discovered that wanting and liking are neurologically distinct. At first blush, this sounds rather obvious and simplistic. At the second blush, it sounds a bit off kilter. Why would someone want something they do not like?
|
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Berridge
if one creates a lesion in the wanting system of a rat, the rat will not eat. It will starve to death. But if you force the same rat to eat agreeable food (e.g., something sweet) it will display behavior that suggests it enjoys the experience. It likes food, but it doesn’t want food. Conversely, one can stimulate the wanting system to achieve wanting without liking. A rat in this condition will eat everything you give it, including food that it dislikes. It will gorge itself on foods that cause it to display aversive reactions at every bite. Berridge compares this to addiction. Addicts often pursue their drug of choice even after that drug no longer induces pleasure.
following research by Kent C. Berridge —“liking and wanting are actually dissociable and… reside in different neural systems.”
|
Dissociation (neuropsychology) - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia)
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by David Pearce
mesolimbic dopamine mediates "wanting", activation of the mu opioid receptors in our twin hedonic hotspots mediates "liking". Experimentally, happiness and motivation are doubly dissociable. Yet if we want to be superhappy and hypermotivated, there's no technical reason why we can't combine the blessings of both.
|
Quote:
Originally Posted by Mr. Blonde
It's impossible to "want" (aka plan something in the future) and NOT experience stress
|
Quote:
Originally Posted by Mr. Blonde
people who desire do not desire still DO THINGS
|
I don’t think these are true, meditative and motivated bliss are equally enjoyable as far as I know but meditative bliss which I see (AND COULD STILL BE GETTING THE WRONG END OF THE STICK) as all pleasure ‘liking’ without desire ‘wanting’ isn’t going to work in the world of fitness and selection pressure. Without thought for the future what would be the motivation to prevent future suffering?
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by David Pearce
Mainlining heroin and Buddhist nirvana have a lot in common, namely bliss and the cessation of all desire. But we need to explore sustainable solutions instead.
|
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by hand selected not with context
If ANYTHING, buddhism is about action
It's not that buddhists don't desire --- in fact they accept that they will be desiring for the rest of their lives. It is the human condition to. It is more the acceptance that you will always desire, as a human being, because that's just part of you are.
aka Buddhists don't get "blissed out" and become desireless zombies. They just stop desiring for personal gain and desire to help others instead.
|
I still don’t understand how Buddhists wouldn’t want to be a desireless wireheader if desire is suffering (it’s not)
“May all that hath life be delivered from suffering"