![]() |
|
|
#26 (permalink) |
|
Gangnam Style
Join Date: Oct 2003
Location: DH's Massage Parlor
Posts: 6,383
Internets: 213510
|
I'm going to retort Orgazmo. I've done some looking at direct comparisons between madden and NFL 2k5, here's the results.
Gamespot: If you were to ask us point-blank what football game you should buy this year, our answer would be "both." With ESPN being a mere $20 and Madden still offering an excellent game of football, we think this is the year that everybody should try both games to truly see where their loyalties lie. Now then, if your response to this statement is, "Nice try, Richie Rich, but I don't have $70 to spend on two football games. Now quit the crap, and tell me which one I should get!" Our answer would be: ESPN NFL 2K5. The reasons for this are plentiful. Aside from our contention that there has never been a better-looking football game than this one, ESPN NFL 2K5 also has more than enough depth in both gameplay and features to make it a stellar package. The new ESPN presentational components, the few gameplay additions to the running game and defense, and the übercool online league system simply make ESPN impossible to pass up. This answer doesn't even take into account the fact that this outstanding package can be purchased for the kind of money you'd typically spend on a crappy budget game. How can you go wrong with a deal like this? With this said, there are a couple of things that Madden does do better. If your sole interest is in having the best franchise mode and you don't particularly care about gameplay or graphics or any of that craziness, then Madden may be the way to go. Additionally, if you really prefer a good, defensive game of football, then Madden has ESPN beaten in that category as well. But, beyond these couple of scant categories, ESPN is really the way to go pretty much across every other conceivable area. While defense may typically win championships, it doesn't win our crown for the best football game of 2004. ESPN NFL 2K5 does that. Team Xbox considered it a tie, despite ESPN taking 3 of the 4 categories. Gamespy declares that it depends on the features... Picking one game as the "best" is extremely tough to do, as both have a lot of good and some not so good. In the end, if you're a big franchise guy, Madden 2005 is the safer choice unless you're a masochist and wish to control every team by yourself in ESPN 2K5. If getting online is your thing, then ESPN is the game to get. If you don't care about franchise play or playing online and would rather just play the occasional exhibition game by yourself or with a buddy on the same machine, then ESPN is still the better choice. Oh, Shaw, sorry I forgot to add Gamespy: Graphics: The One-Sided Fight It's here where ESPN 2K5 has one of its big advantages. First off, ESPN is the best-looking football game ever made, hands down, end of conversation. The animations, the fluidity of the players, everything is flat-out gorgeous. After playing ESPN, Madden looks stiff and rigid and the player models look "off" by comparison. EA Sports isn't used to playing second fiddle in the graphics department, but that's definitely the case this year. ESPN NFL 2K5 When you combine the brilliant graphics with the wonderful ESPN broadcast presentation, it's clear that ESPN 2K5 holds a huge lead in the "eye candy and frills" department. It has a great replay system that sucks you into the action as well as the Chris Berman halftime and post game shows. It helps create the illusion that you're watching a real game, and are part of a real league, better than any sports game ever made. The audio is also an ESPN strong suit. While EA Sports has the recognizable names of Al Michaels and John Madden, ESPN has by far the better commentary. The commentators discuss the replays and actually make fairly astute observations about what's happening on the field. Madden and Michaels sound completely disinterested, and it hurts the overall atmosphere. |
|
|
|
|
|
#27 (permalink) |
|
Sex Kitten Milf fuuucck
Join Date: Feb 2002
Location: Denver, CO
Posts: 3,704
Internets: 55974
|
Shaw where is this madden tournament at in Warsaw?
For the record I just beat Nieter yesterday in a game, so if u want to play someobdy play either of us. |
|
There's life and then there is Cubs baseball, it's a chore to seperate the two.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
#28 (permalink) |
|
Senior Member
Join Date: Jul 2003
Location: Warsaw
Posts: 4,220
Internets: 124047
|
well ill ball against both of you...just gotta get at the cell phone...i heard i gave you drunken call about the hoosiers on saturday...the madden tourney is january 22nd at chimps comix...registration is at 11 and game play starts at 12...
|
|
Nubblies: If we put up with Felix, we will put up with you too.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
#29 (permalink) | |
|
Senior Member
Join Date: Jul 2003
Location: Warsaw
Posts: 4,220
Internets: 124047
|
Quote:
| |
|
Nubblies: If we put up with Felix, we will put up with you too.
|
||
|
|
|
|
|
#30 (permalink) |
|
I like dirt.
|
I just have to say something here. I'm not a big computer/gaming graphics guy, but I don't really see a difference in the pictures you posted, fethreelix. The first time I looked at them, I thought they were all from the same game. I'll admit that I haven't played either of them, but seeing as how you're so pro-ESPN and anti-Madden, my guess is that you found the best ESPN pictures possible and the worst Madden pictures possible. Since they both look the same to me, it tells me that Madden is probably better.
Another plus about Madden? I don't have to listen to Berman's voice. God that man is annoying. Not like Madden is a special treat or anything, but I'd take him over Berman any day. |
|
|
|
|
|
#31 (permalink) |
|
Senior Member
Join Date: Jul 2003
Location: Warsaw
Posts: 4,220
Internets: 124047
|
You have to understand, graphics can only go so far with a video game. Now if ESPN does have better graphics, so be it....i know for a fact they dont have the online play nor just the overall gameplay that madden does...that cant be touched by anyone makin a football game besides ea sports...now next year..madden will be the best ever and I for one cant wait!!!!!!
|
|
Nubblies: If we put up with Felix, we will put up with you too.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
#32 (permalink) | ||
|
Gangnam Style
Join Date: Oct 2003
Location: DH's Massage Parlor
Posts: 6,383
Internets: 213510
|
Quote:
Gamespot: Features: Online ESPN The big shift in online for ESPN this year is a complete overhaul of the league system. Last year's leagues were pretty bare-bones, but this year's are really quite something. Aside from the ability to track stats and results from a pretty-slick-looking, ESPN-themed Web page, the game hosts live rosters for the purpose of tracking injuries and allowing for trades between teams. Going back to the Web site stuff for a second... Did we mention how slick these features are? You can get full play-by-plays for each game, look up all the player stats you'd expect to see on a real NFL stat-tracking site, and get your message board on with your fellow league members. You've also got the choice between full seasons or simple tournaments for your leagues. It's all really, really cool stuff. Outside of the leagues, you've got all the usual head-to-head-play stuff, as well as a built-in ESPN messaging system and the ability to download an opponent's user profile in hopes of using it to train against him (more on that on the next page). Since the game launched, it has had its share of issues online, but things seem to be running pretty smoothly now. And for the record, we haven't had a single problem getting into a game online since the most recent fixes went up, nor have we experienced any game glitches. Madden Madden is supposedly going to have its own premium pass league system at some point, but as it stands, none of it is currently up and running. Furthermore, it won't have live rosters. It will have most of ESPN's other league features, however. More premium pass stuff includes some exclusive leaderboards, a customizable sports ticker, and so on. But to access any of it, you'll have to enter a credit card number and sign up for the crazy premium service (although it's supposedly still free). Outside of standard head-to-head play (of which there is plenty), you can also play one of Madden's minigames online (more on that on the next page), as well as check out profiles of other users online to familiarize yourself with their play styles and tendencies (not available via download, though). Also worth noting is the fact that Madden is on Xbox Live for the first time this year, and whatever rookie mistakes might have been made in last month's NCAA Football 2005 appear to be absent for Madden. The game plays great over Live. Which is better? Despite whatever technical issues may have existed for ESPN (which, again, we never really encountered), the fact remains that ESPN has the best available list of online features available today. All of EA's league stuff is untested and theoretical until it launches "near the beginning of the season," and what ESPN has in terms of leagues is just cooler, features-wise. And while EA's premium stuff sounds cool, it doesn't seem cool enough to really warrant the extra hassle of giving them a credit card number. We'll see when it goes up, but for right now, ESPN is most definitely where the online business is at. Winner: ESPN NFL 2K5 From Team Xbox: Online play Rob: Aside from a few performance issues in both games, both play extremely well online. I don't think it can be overstated how important having Madden on Live is. Regardless of what the EA haters out there will say, everyone wants to know how good you are at Madden. However, the entire online package has to go to ESPN though, just for the VIP features and player trades alone. Brent: Madden is a standard in the industry, and people will want to know how good everybody else is, but it still doesn’t hold up to how valuable the VIP system is for online play. Dale: Madden has the real-time ticker and reputation system which are both cool, but ESPN brings more to the table for real online players. And, VIP=next gen. Nuff ‘ced. Rob: Ya. Being in a tourney and scouting the upcoming opposition, being able to download their VIP and simulate a game is amazing. The VIP system should be implemented in every sports game from here on out, not to mention fighters, etc. Brent: Another one for ESPN? Dale: Yep. Rob: Definitely. Online play winner: ESPN NFL 2K5 Shaw, please stop being ignorant, as you obviously haven't played ESPN, so quit saying one thing is better than the other, when you haven't experienced both. Quote:
| ||
|
|
|
|
|
#33 (permalink) |
|
Senior Member
Join Date: Feb 2002
Posts: 6,150
Internets: 284753
|
Personally f3lix, you seem like the type of person who only likes ESPN b/c everyone else likes Madden.
Also, you spend way too much fucking time trying to convince people that ESPN is better. News flash buddy: most people have played both, and most people here still like Madden more. Aren't you in school? Don't you have any studying you could do? In all honesty I don't think anyone is going to read that post. I sure as hell didn't. [ January 14, 2005, 12:09 PM: Message edited by: Dirty Harry ] |
|
|
|
|
|
#34 (permalink) |
|
Senior Member
Join Date: Jul 2003
Location: Warsaw
Posts: 4,220
Internets: 124047
|
yeah quite frankly that post was mostly for me and i read the first 3 words i think. Listen, you can find stuff for or against madden...if i wanted to spend time i could look something up that said madden is god and espn is shit...But i prefer to spend my time actually playing the video games rather then lookin up stuff on them...Last night toke one on the chin in madden online vs. the 765th best player in the world...lost by 10..not a bad game by any means...GO COLTS!!!
|
|
Nubblies: If we put up with Felix, we will put up with you too.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
#35 (permalink) |
|
I like dirt.
|
Featherlicks,
Yes, I've read the thread. That's why I posted in it. In fact I have read every post carefully except for the majority of yours because if I wanted to read whatever you're posting, then I can just look up stuff on the games myself. Next time just use links. I would wager that two people at most have read every word of your posts. I get the point. The graphics are said to be better. The truth is, from the pictures you posted, I don't see much of a difference. I personally take my opinion over that of others, that's why it's my opinion. On stupid shit like this, you have to stick with your own opinion, because that's all that matters. For instance, I like the movies 'Garden State' and 'Adaptation'. My friends Dirty Harry and Orgazmo do not like these movies and have said so on the boards. So, say Dirty Harry and Orgazmo decide to look up 30 million reviews on these two movies, like you did, and post them here. Would I stop liking these movies? No. In closing, stop these long ass posts of stuff that other people wrote. Oh...and burn in hell. tonguegina P.S. I'm glad to hear Berman doesn't do play by play. |
|
|
|
|
|
#36 (permalink) |
|
Sex Kitten Milf fuuucck
Join Date: Feb 2002
Location: Denver, CO
Posts: 3,704
Internets: 55974
|
EA sports games are just better in general. I own both 2k5 and NBA Live 2005 and Live is far superior. Graphics wise they are both comparable. Gameplay wise Live and Madden are slightly better. Presentation isn't even a contest. ESPN games simply suck huge cock and balls in presentation, they leave out so many little things that make the game so much better its sickening. I peronsally will never buy an ESPN game again.
|
|
There's life and then there is Cubs baseball, it's a chore to seperate the two.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
#37 (permalink) |
|
Senior Member
Join Date: Jul 2003
Location: Warsaw
Posts: 4,220
Internets: 124047
|
BDH is much more educated then me and said everything i try to say just in a much better manor...so there..that is my opinion..little does he know he is going to get pounded by the colts tonight!!!!
|
|
Nubblies: If we put up with Felix, we will put up with you too.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
#38 (permalink) |
|
Senior Member
Join Date: Feb 2002
Posts: 6,150
Internets: 284753
|
Actually Tounge, I don't recall ever saying I didn't like Garden State, I probably said I thought it looked like shit, but I never saw the movie until a few days ago. I liked it. Adaptation is still gay.
[ January 14, 2005, 04:58 PM: Message edited by: Dirty Harry ] |
|
|
|
|
|
#42 (permalink) |
|
Sex Kitten Milf fuuucck
Join Date: Feb 2002
Location: Denver, CO
Posts: 3,704
Internets: 55974
|
Shaw nailed me pretty good, I had some difficulties early but started to come around late I think the score was somewhere around 80-50 shaw. I think if it were a rematch it would be a lower scoring affair and still the same outcome of a shaw victory.
|
|
There's life and then there is Cubs baseball, it's a chore to seperate the two.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
#43 (permalink) |
|
Senior Member
Join Date: Feb 2002
Location: U.S.A.
Posts: 13,643
Internets: 247330
|
Thats one thing I don't like about Madden - how the scores escalate to unreal levels. I scored 113 points on Orgazmo the other day (admittedly, after about the first 30 points, he threw in the towel and let me score at will more-or-less). Maybe if the computer defense was a little better or something...I dunno, it just erks me. Everything else about the game is real-to-life. Why can't the final scores of some of the games be that way too?
-Ugly Bastard [ January 15, 2005, 01:44 AM: Message edited by: Ugly Bastard ] |
|
|
|
|
|
#44 (permalink) |
|
Gangnam Style
Join Date: Oct 2003
Location: DH's Massage Parlor
Posts: 6,383
Internets: 213510
|
Shaw, I should figure you wouldn't read any of the post, b/c you made up your mind already. That is fine if you think that madden is supurior, I have no problem with that. What I do have a problem with, is you saying to others that it is in the manner in which you did. You haven't played 2k5, so you really don't have validity to say such things. The game reviewers (who do this for a living) nearly unanimously cleaned Madden off the floor with their reviews. User reviews also show 2k5 at a 9.2 against Madden's 8.3 I personally left Madden b/c the game just doesn't change enough for me and they charge a rediculous amount for a slightly improved game.
Tongue, you anology doesn't work. You compared it to liking something, which is subjected; compared to better graphics which is much more objective. Look at the body types, the arms, the curvative of the helmets, the body types, etc... Admitting that you don't know what to look for drops your credibility and makes your statements moot. Harry, I like the 2k5 series and have been a fan since the original 2k games on Dreamcast. I've always been a fan b/c the gameplay is solid and the layout of the game is well put together. ESPN's presentation of NFL 2k5 is just sick. This is why I pick ESPN games. BDH, I completely disagree w/ you on the presentation factor, as do all of the professional reviewers. While I agree the NBA 2k5 isn't as good as NFL 2k5, It still is put together well and doesn't have player glitches like NBA Live does. Live just pisses me off with the random stupidness of the players not playing help-side defense. |
|
|
|
|
|
#45 (permalink) |
|
Sex Kitten Milf fuuucck
Join Date: Feb 2002
Location: Denver, CO
Posts: 3,704
Internets: 55974
|
UB if you played All-Madden while playing Gaz' I'm sure it wouldn't be 100 points scored.
|
|
There's life and then there is Cubs baseball, it's a chore to seperate the two.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
#46 (permalink) |
|
Senior Member
Join Date: Feb 2002
Location: U.S.A.
Posts: 13,643
Internets: 247330
|
Ya, his computer always picks off like 15 of my passes though, and that erks me too.
Basically, I'm just bitching. I know it's not EAs fault. -Ugly Bastard [ January 15, 2005, 02:14 AM: Message edited by: Ugly Bastard ] |
|
|
|
|
|
#47 (permalink) |
|
Senior Member
Join Date: Jul 2003
Location: Warsaw
Posts: 4,220
Internets: 124047
|
I then after beating BDH, i bet Nieter and toney then nieter again then was playing him neiter for the 3rd time and had already drank a few....and he was up when we quit playing...it was a good one!!!
|
|
Nubblies: If we put up with Felix, we will put up with you too.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
#48 (permalink) |
|
Nasty Nate
Join Date: Aug 2003
Location: Michigan
Posts: 627
Internets: 4881
|
I play madden online, very rarely though, I haven't played much madden at all lately. I always go with the Lions, even though statstically on the game they aren't that great. Ive always supported the home team here in michigan though.
I really wish I knew more about football defense though. When you watch games they make it all sound so simply, but when im playing the game and trying to pick plays, sometimes im clueless. I understand the formations and what each man is doing, but often I call the wrong play in the wrong situation. When I play against the CPU alot of times I just "ask madden", but when your playing online you cant really do that, since online players aren't predictable, and dont do the expected. Oh btw next year the super bowl is gonna be in Ford Field here in Detroit. I heard that for the halftime show they are thinking about having a mo-town theme. It would be kinda cool to have eminem or kid rock do something since they are from michigan, but I think everyones still hesitant to do anything like that since the whole janet jackson thing. |
|
|
|
![]() |
| Bookmarks |
|
|