Quote:
Originally Posted by Mr. Blonde
Am I correct that your overall summed-up opinion is that machines will forever be excluded from experiencing consciousness equivalent to a human or even animal?
|
Humans and non-human animals* Yes
Take a look at number 3. (from George Dvorsky 'You'll Probably Never Upload Your Mind Into A Computer')
1. Brain functions are not computable
2. We'll never solve the hard problem of consciousness
3. We'll never solve the binding problem
4. Panpsychism is true
5. Mind-body dualism is true
6. It would be unethical to develop
7. We can never be sure it works
8. Uploaded minds would be vulnerable to hacking and abuse
From
Are there problems with the metaphor of mind-uploading?
(1) Transhumanists are materialists/physicalists.
(2) Materialists/physicalists do not view the mind as a “thing” that is separate from the human brain.
(3) The transference thesis (and uploading more generally) assumes that the mind is a thing that is separate from the human brain.
(4) Therefore, transhumanists cannot believe in the transference thesis (and uploading more generally).