![]() |
|
|
#1 (permalink) |
|
Senior Member
Join Date: Dec 2003
Location: My Machine
Posts: 460
Internets: -238
|
In light of the recent response concerning the whereabouts of this new thread,
[See Victim: *below* me]. ...I’ve edited this initial post (and the post from the Original Source:Confessional/AdviceLine's: A Letter to Myself). If you haven’t already, read starting Dec. 10th for the full meaning behind the thread's title. The proposition for this thread: This is a Rant Topics include but are not Necessarily limited to: Existence Vs. Non-Existence of ‘God’ or a supreme being Before Life, Life, Death & Beyond. Heaven, Hell, and the present moment. & Organized Vs. Agnostic/Atheist Religion The only requirement is that you enter with a Stand/Position and that you’re prepared to defend it. I’m also going to take this opportunity to throw in a plug for The Arts: Strange Mental Currencies thread in which you should: Post any poetry or images that illustrate in artistic form (mspaint, text, adobe, whatever your medium) the topics we are discussing here. The art would definitely add to the discussion. Just remember to critique your immediate predecessor before you post your reply (Yes, the thread UB barrowed the idea from). In effort to make this a good thread just keep in mind: Make it worthy of Nubblies Nuff said. Commence banter. [btw- Victim, thanks for the tips. 'll definately be in mind for the next thread creation] Attention All: Stab brought up a good point on the discussion of these topics. Similar issues to these have been discussed before, why not use them? While (at least for the moment [particular questions still in progress]) it seems more beneficial to keep this current thread, I'm going to make a list of links at the bottom of this post to serve as a resource for Rant Material and easy accessibility for grabbing prior quotes. I've found one so far, the searching hasn't been easy. If you come across or remember a thread that deals in the same or similar topics PM me and I'll add it to the list. SUPREME BEING CURSE ME, about fucking time to get RANTING. List of related LINKS w/ Thread Starter Atheists CAN go to Heaven - Professor Number [ December 13, 2003, 12:24 AM: Message edited by: Percipere'Chan ] |
|
Dead, death, grim on a pale horse, empty, hollow, inanimate, fataled, black curtained, annihilated.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
#2 (permalink) |
|
Senior Member
Join Date: Nov 2002
Posts: 985
Internets: 10
|
Percipere'Chan, most new threads, especially new threads "worthy of Nubblies" as you so deftly put it, actually explain the motivation for the thread and where it came from, instead of just vaguely insinuating at its origin. By the way, to all the people at home that are just tuning in, this thread is derived from comments made in the "A letter to myself" thread.
Usually, I can comprehend (even enjoy) your vague, rambling posts slathered with self-indulgent, quasi-intellectual language but you sent me on a bit of an unappreciated scavenger hunt with this thread... fucker. Now, where were we? |
|
get off my internet!!!
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
#4 (permalink) |
|
Senior Member
Join Date: Dec 2003
Location: My Machine
Posts: 460
Internets: -238
|
Okay, I hate messy arguments. Right now that’s just what we have on our hands. I think right now it’s up to Pliedes to Clean up his Posts.
Summary (extremely abbreviated version): DH – “I don’t believe in Hell”. Pli - "Just because you don't believe it doesn't mean it's not true". Titan - “Just because you do, doesn’t mean it does. *Pli- “[above quote] not a rule”. “used to show people fault in stated position”. Titan – “[*everyone’s head spins]” No offense Pli, but that sounded like one hell (no pun intended) of a campaign for being able to use an ontological argument in support of your position. I knew where you were going with it as soon as you started and it still made my head spin (thanks Titan). So the task put before you Pliedes is this, Clean up this mess: Rule or Simple Statement What "Inherent" Flaw? Is your Argument on the “Inherent Flaw” going to be based Ontologically or Not? (cool either way just make it clear). Go. [ December 14, 2003, 06:04 PM: Message edited by: Percipere'Chan ] |
|
Dead, death, grim on a pale horse, empty, hollow, inanimate, fataled, black curtained, annihilated.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
#5 (permalink) |
|
Senior Member
Join Date: Oct 2002
Location: Puget Sound
Posts: 4,594
Internets: 1608
|
First of all, let's not get ahead of ourselves. I didn't actually state my position. (though Percipitation, being the clever fellow he is, added followed it to it's result)
At the time, Dirty Harry had just made the comment "I don't believe in hell". And I replied with "Just because you don't believe in something, doens't mean it doesn't exist". Now, what I was stating at the time was more of a general comment on attitudes. The little kid in "The Santa Clause" provides us with an example. His step-father was trying to convince him that Santa Claus does not exist, and when he stated..."I've never seen Santa Clause", to which the child responds "Have you ever seen a million dollars?", [step-father replies] "No." [child again] "That doesn't mean it doesn't exist." In the same way, I was simply saying that a person believing something does not exist, does not mean that it doesn't exist. It only means that a person doesn't believe in it. -BUT- (and this is where Percipitation connected the dots) If we can in any way state that something has an underlying validity beyond a state such as human belief then it ultimately is an ontological arguement. [I hope that clears things up, Percy] I'm still not ready to dive head first into all this jazz, but something Hank brought up in another thread which caught my eye, was Pascal's wager. I think many nubblites will find it interesting, as many are gambling men. It's actually really simple, and as follows: If you place your bets on God existing and you are right, you have much to gain, and if you are wrong, you lose nothing. Whereas if you place your bet on God not existing, and you are wrong, you have much to lose, but if you are right, you gain nothing. Or as Pascal said, "If you gain, you gain all; if you lose, you lose nothing." Extremely generalized, but that's what he was getting at. Let's bat that around for a while. |
|
|
|
|
|
#6 (permalink) |
|
Senior Member
Join Date: Feb 2002
Posts: 6,150
Internets: 284753
|
The French philosopher Blaise Pascal (1623-1662), realizing that all the traditional proofs were inconclusive, asked the question instead, "Since we are all betting our lives, either for or against God, what is the best bet to make?" He concluded that the best bet would be to believe in God. Even if he should not exist, we still experience the immense joy of believing and will lose no more than a few paltry pleasures of the flesh, while if we refuse to believe, we experience at best only a few questionable pleasures but deny ourselves the greatest happiness this life can provide. And if God should exist, then the believer not only knows the joy of belief here but will experience eternal life with God hereafter, while the unbeliever not only misses the blessings of life with God in the present but loses his very soul for all eternity. Belief thus offers the most to gain and the least to lose.
Criticisms Objectors ask how one can be expected to honestly believe what he/she simply can't believe? If no solid evidence for the existence of the deity can be found, then reason dictates that belief must either be suspended (agnosticism) or denied (atheism). One should not surrender one's intellectual integrity or respect for truth merely for the unsupportable hope of some kind of either earthly or eternal bliss, or both, in case one might be mistaken. While we're at it, let's discuss the moral argument for the existance of God. One version of this argument, made famous by Immanuel Kant, says that even though good will is the only unconditioned good, justice still requires that good people should be happy and bad people unhappy. But the reverse is all too often the case. Therefore, if morality is to be justified, there must be another life where people will receive their proper rewards and punishments, and if there is such a life, God must be responsible for it. Also, we have an unlimited capacity for moral goodness, yet our lives come to an end long before we have even begun to fulfill this moral potential. Therefore, there must be another life where this capacity can be realized. And if this is so, then there must be a God who is responsible for it. Otherwise, life is unexplaniedly unjust and unfair. Any thoughts/comments on either of these? If you'd like to hear any of the other types of major arguments for the existance of God, such as the teleological, cosmological, or ontological arguments, and their criticisms just say the word. [ December 15, 2003, 04:21 PM: Message edited by: Dirty Harry ] |
|
|
|
|
|
#7 (permalink) |
|
Senior Member
Join Date: May 2003
Posts: 1,215
Internets: 3373
|
Excellent posts people.
I feel that many people misinterpreted my message in the original "Athiests can go to heaven" thread. My beliefs in God closely follow those of Transcendentalism. In the early 19th century, the Harvard-educated me such as Emerson began to read the scriptures of eastern religions, namely Hinduism and Buddhism. After doing so they examined their own religious assumptions against the scriptures of eastern religions. "In their perspective, a loving God would not have led so much of humanity astray; there must be truth in these scriptures, too." Truth, if it agreed with an individual's intuition of truth, must be indeed truth. Hence, I took that theory one step further resulting in my belief that Athiests are capable of getting into Heaven. Let me stress this fact: I believe in God. However, it seems completely illogical and counter-religious for God to turn his back on such a large amount of people; athiests included. |
|
Smoke a cigarette and lie some more -- These conversations kill.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
#8 (permalink) |
|
1 thing leads to another.
Join Date: Feb 2002
Posts: 2,012
Internets: -2654
|
i will not be participating in this thread, simply because of the extreme gayness of the title
and i don't want to read everyone's posts [img]smile.gif[/img] but to quickly to professor: *** seems completely illogical and counter-religious for God to turn his back on such a large amount of people; athiests included. *** how so? would seem to me the atheists especially are turning their backs on God. God made free human will...we make our own decisions, and that's a good thing. alright, I'm done. and P'Chan: I read the shit talking post or whatever the hell it is...I have no idea what the fuck an 'OST' is. sounds jake-kiernish though. if you want to argue on the topic, i'd be willing I'm not going to post in this thread, simply because your making a joke of it to begin with. Fuck you [img]smile.gif[/img] . Start something like, 'Atheists Can go to heaven....', and I'll reply. |
|
___________________
3:o) horned creatures...wat wat ___________________ |
|
|
|
|
|
|
#9 (permalink) |
|
Senior Member
Join Date: May 2003
Posts: 1,215
Internets: 3373
|
Active -
One simple question: Are hindus and Buddhists going to hell? Alright, enough bullshit. Let's settle this in a proper thread (located here) [ December 15, 2003, 09:36 PM: Message edited by: ProfessorNumber ] |
|
Smoke a cigarette and lie some more -- These conversations kill.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
#10 (permalink) |
|
Senior Member
Join Date: Oct 2002
Location: Puget Sound
Posts: 4,594
Internets: 1608
|
PN, are you saying that because God is loving he wouldn't send people to hell?
Secondly, do you understand the concept of freewill? If so, explain it to me. "Are hindus and Buddhists going to hell?" -If you're speaking within the context of Christianity, then yes. |
|
|
|
![]() |
| Bookmarks |
|
|