![]() |
|
|
#26 (permalink) |
|
I like dirt.
|
Just watched it. Not bad. It's not as good as The Dark Knight, but it's better than the average comic book movie. It gets major points for being adult oriented. Definitely not one for the whole family.
I know this is kind of a mediocre review, but there's a lot to take in. I'm told it's a shit load better if you read the graphic novel first and know what's going on. I feel like I either need to read the graphic novel or see it again to fully appreciate it. |
|
|
|
|
|
#28 (permalink) |
|
I like dirt.
|
I realize. I'm quite often disappointed by movies after I've read the book. So I wanted to try seeing the movie first this time. Now, I think I should have tried to read it first. That's all I'm saying.
|
|
Last edited by tonguegina; 03-05-2009 at 02:04 PM. |
|
|
|
|
|
|
#29 (permalink) | |
|
*Dislikes ham
Senior Member
Join Date: Jul 2005
Location: HELL 666
Posts: 1,518
Internets: 60790
|
Quote:
| |
|
Putting the sensual in non-consensual.
|
||
|
|
|
|
|
#33 (permalink) | |
|
I make bad decisions.
|
Quote:
I might try to catch an early show of this today before work. | |
|
|
|
|
|
#34 (permalink) |
|
Ahoy Fuckbag
Join Date: Sep 2008
Location: In a pineapple under the sea
Posts: 3,540
Internets: 187030
|
Saw it this morning and my biggest gripe is that all the details that made the book good, and complex, and captivating: gone.
Visually - very solid. Casting - very solid. Fight scenes - very solid. Soundtrack - very weak. Pacing - seemed off. I am really on the fence with this movie; I don't think it is good enough to stand alone for those who have never read the graphic novel and I don't think it does a very good job of bringing the essence of the graphic novel to life. I plan to see it again, I may have just been out of sorts because I received a phone call from my old boss about 10 minutes into the film and spent the whole 2.5 hours after that worrying about why he would be calling me (was expecting it to be bad news). |
|
Quote:
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
#35 (permalink) |
|
Spice Master
Join Date: Jan 2004
Posts: 17,969
Internets: 284106
|
Just caught it at a theater I passed downtown earlier today. It was in English with Korean subtitles, and the theater was probably less than 1/3rd full...which is fine. It was interesting, especially since apparently there were assigned seats which
A. I didn't know beforehand, I think the ticket girl tried to tell me but I can't understand the broken English here for shit, thats something I need to work at...even at the Korean consulate in Chicago I couldn't understand what the fuck the cute processor girl was telling me. Whatever. B. I sat in other peoples seats...TWICE and had to get up. It wasn't too bad, mostly they were just standing there and looked at their ticket and I figured out the first time that I was in wrong seat and just got up and moved. After the second time, I moved to an area nobody was sitting at on the right hand side till the movie had started. Awkward... Another funny anecdote before I get to the spoilers, is that it was awkward being the only Anglo in a theater full of Asians, when 3 separate times in the movie (Vietnam War, Gang attacking in the alley, and prisoners during the riot) Asians were the ones receiving a major ass-kicking at the hands of Americans. I'm sure it was just me being paranoid, but when The Comedian shoots the Vietnamese chick pregnant with his child I definitely sank in my seat a little bit. Now, onto the movie review: I thought it was fucking great. The visual comparison to the graphic novel is astounding, down to the very last detail. There are only a few things I thought should have stayed to their initial plot, tiny things mostly, like Captain Metropolis not being part of the movie at all really, and them replacing him with Ozzy during the meeting of the Watchmen where The Comedian burns the map. The BIG thing I have a problem with, which DDTempest and I talked about a couple months ago, was the ending. I really don't see why they couldn't go with the way it was in the comics...with the alien monster and only happening in New York. Blaming everything on Dr. Manhattan was just kind of a bullshit move, but I can see how they could do such an easy transition, especially with him leaving the planet at the end in the graphic novel anyways. Still; I don't think they did a good job with explaining enough how the Comedian was able to keep quiet from telling Nixon about him finding out about what Ozzie was doing, and why he was keeping quiet in the first place (see: the end of the movie, and everyone realizing why they have to keep quiet). But yes, overall, fucking great movie. Moreso just a visualization thing for me, same with the Lord of the Rings books, and pretty much every book to movie ever for most people I guess. They are always going to leave some cool shit out, because of time limits or whatever other reasons, but directors that stay true to the perceived visualization of readers of the books or graphic novel in this case are the really good ones. |
|
|
|
|
|
#36 (permalink) |
|
I make bad decisions.
|
Kinda funny about the assigned seating thing.
I'll refrain from reading the "spoilers" until after I watch this, although I read the book. Definitely going today, preferably to the first show after I wake up. |
|
Last edited by SittinOnDubsWGW; 03-08-2009 at 08:45 AM. |
|
|
|
|
|
|
#37 (permalink) |
|
I make bad decisions.
|
Loved it. My biggest gripe throughout the film, the soundtrack. It just seemed really really out of sync with the film. I read several reviews before seeing it and the biggest complaints seemed to be running time,"shocking amount of sex and violence" (see next paragraph), and that it was really slow paced.
I was utterly dumbfounded at the amount of elementary aged children were brought to the movie with their parents. As it clearly states rated R for graphic violence, nudity, and language. It definitely had all of the above in ample supply. I saw a couple parents walk out with their kids, one couple was close to me and said "this is absolutely ridiculous, we can't let our children watch this!" (Their two children were probably 10-12). I thought the pacing of the film wasn't too bad, I never felt uninterested and really didn't feel like I was sitting there for three hours. Also, the sex scene was definitely skinemax style and i chuckled at it. |
|
|
|
|
|
#38 (permalink) |
|
MURICAN
|
I usually hate these movies, and I was embarrased that I went to see this one:
But I loved it! It's fresh! Mmmmm it just made me so happy. |
![]() The basis of our governments being the opinion of the people, the very first object should be to keep that right; and were it left to me to decide whether we should have a government without newspapers, or newspapers without a government, I should not hesitate a moment to prefer the latter. But I should mean that every man should receive those papers and be capable of reading them. ![]() |
|
|
|
|
|
|
#40 (permalink) |
|
*Dislikes ham
Senior Member
Join Date: Jul 2005
Location: HELL 666
Posts: 1,518
Internets: 60790
|
Movie was awesome, if you don't think so you're a faggot. End thread.
Oh wait, Secret Blue Cock makes a number of appearances threw the film. Now you can end thread. |
|
Putting the sensual in non-consensual.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
#42 (permalink) |
|
Lost in Hilbert Spice
Join Date: Jun 2004
Location: Surrounded by knaves and fools
Posts: 3,528
Internets: 183146
|
Loved it.
Although I had meant to read the book from the advice in the first post, I never got round to it, the first 5 minutes were amazing, how they made it cartoony-real, and I don't think the Bob Dylan song was out of place, the 99 red ballons was a little off, but I still liked how it blended the serialness with comic book. Why is it that the owner of SBC doesn't just stop the war/destroy the nukes anyway? I heard something about tachyon's but was too taken aback by A HUGE GLOWING FUCKING BLUE DUDE to try to understand. |
|
|
|
|
|
#43 (permalink) |
|
Spice Master
Join Date: Jan 2004
Posts: 17,969
Internets: 284106
|
Great points dent. Thought the beginning/extreme slow mo through time was an excellent way to start the film, and the Bob Dylan song was greatly placed. 99 Red balloons (and a couple others I can't think of) were weird, but it didn't stay in the foreground of sound for long.
|
|
|
|
|
|
#44 (permalink) |
|
*Dislikes ham
Senior Member
Join Date: Jul 2005
Location: HELL 666
Posts: 1,518
Internets: 60790
|
When Rorschach said "I'm not locked in with you, you're locked in with me!" I pulled a Pee Wee Herman and started to masturbate right there in the theater.
|
|
Putting the sensual in non-consensual.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
#45 (permalink) |
|
Emperor Meow
|
I finally saw it tonight. It was bad, really bad. I especially hate how they didn't give you any sense of the old school masked avengers except through a crappy montage at the beginning of the movie (wtf who puts a montage at the beginning of a movie?). It was unnecessarily long which was expected but they left all the cool shit out and just over styled crap with long music sequences, the soundtrack was almost comical sometimes, the majority of the lines delivered came off extremely cheesy, how horrible were the prison scenes?, etc etc
|
|
#YOLO
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
#46 (permalink) | |
|
Been told twice
Join Date: Jan 2009
Posts: 312
Internets: 1299
|
Quote:
Cause the old school avengers got basically the exact same treatment in the movie as they did in the book, where we learned about them almost exclusively in flashbacks and clippings (from Under the Hood and other sources). They didn't play an active role in the main plot of the book any more than they did in the movie. They did skip over the murder of Hollis Mason, but there is an hour of additional material that was cut that will be released on the DVD. Also the "cheesy" lines were almost exclusively straight from the book, verbatim. Including the "who would want a cowboy president" bit at the end. I agree that the soundtrack was a bit distracting, but at least one song (all along the watchtower) is also straight out of the book. And once you've committed to using period music to set scenes, you've got to do it all, or it just makes it more jarring when the one song happens. And using song lyrics to parallel what is happening on screen actually hearkens back to the parallel imagery between the Tales of the Black Freighter and what the heroes are doing at the same time. The montage was fucking amazing, btw. Almost shot by shot from the book, showing the evolutions of the masked heroes from their height of popularity to their fall from grace to their eventual move to the shadows (Rorschach was PERFECT). Basically, I can't imagine how anyone could claim to like the novel and NOT like this movie. It's the closest thing that could possibly have been done to bring it to life. Even changing the squid plotline into the S.Q.U.I.D project was a stroke of genius. It works BETTER than the original plot because it furthered the theme of Dr. Manhattan as God (the Watchmaker), who in this case became a vengeful god demanding an end to hostilities. The squid would only scare the world for so long before tensions arose again. THe idea of the world being destroyed by an angry superman (even if he IS american) means that there's no more temptation by governments to even try going to war. They can't assume that the fallout will leave the midwest untouched, the way they could under MAD scenarios. When you piss off a GOD, he fucks you completely. Anyway, great movie, and I'm totally buying the DVD for the extra footage, plus the Tales of the Black Freighter. | |
|
|
|
|
|
#47 (permalink) |
|
Ahoy Fuckbag
Join Date: Sep 2008
Location: In a pineapple under the sea
Posts: 3,540
Internets: 187030
|
|
|
Quote:
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
#48 (permalink) |
|
Emperor Meow
|
(second god damn time i wrote this, much shorter, my laptop sux)
Yes, I have read the graphic novel. And a movie is an entirely different medium than a comic book. And when you confine yourself to following the comic exactly all of the nuances of the comic were all lost. It ended up with a film with lots of "stuff" that didn't fit well at all together. I didn't say the lines were cheesy, I said they came off cheesy. A lot of things that worked in the comic came off as cheesy. for example, the scene where Nite Owl cracks Ozy's password literally made me squirm in my chair it was so bad. The movie does not stand on its own. The one shining performance I can say there was is Rorschach, his last scene was awesome. but all the characters come off as cliche cutouts. Unfortunately the only thing thats going to save this movie from being remembered as a complete crapshoot are fanboi's with rose colored glasses and a shit-ton of hype. Dark Knight > Iron Man > Xmen 2 > batman begins > spiderman > hulk 2 > watchmen |
|
#YOLO
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
#49 (permalink) | |
|
Been told twice
Join Date: Jan 2009
Posts: 312
Internets: 1299
|
Quote:
Not to mention that the only thing that keeps countries from riding into each other and fighting old-fashioned style is the idea of mutually assured destruction. Take away the nukes from everyone, and there's nothing to keep the Russians from firebombing as much of the country as they can, while the US does the same thing back. It would have cost even more lives in the long run. That's why it had to happen the way it did. Manhattan didn't see it (from seeing the future) because Veidt had built machines to send tachyons backwards (yeah, pseudoscience plot points) which blocked the way he perceived time. He had to do it in order to hire Janey and Moloch and the others (to expose them to cancer) so he could drive Manhattan away from Earth. God, yeah, complex story. But anyone comparing it to Dark Knight or other comic book stories misses the point. It's not the same genre of movie. It's not an action film. It's an alternate-reality political thriller with some action thrown in. | |
|
|
|
![]() |
| Bookmarks |
|
|